In Other News ·

Obama said he learned about the IRS targeting conservatives 'from the news' — MAZE reminds X his own aides knew weeks earlier

Broken Truth · In Other News

1,975 likes · 729 reposts · 32,000 views

The IRS was singling out Tea Party and "patriot" groups, and the President of the United States said he found out the same way everybody else did: from the news. At a May 13, 2013 press conference Barack Obama said, "I first learned about it from the same news reports that I think most people learned about this. I think it was on Friday."

Within a week, the White House acknowledged that staff in its counsel's office had heard about the coming inspector general's report as early as April 16, and that White House Counsel Kathryn Ruemmler, told it would likely find IRS employees improperly scrutinized groups using words like "tea party" and "patriot," passed that on to chief of staff Denis McDonough and other senior advisers — but, the White House said, not to Obama, AP reported.

Friday morning MAZE (@mazemoore) posted the clip: "The President said that he heard about it on the news. Even more ridiculous, the media went along with it." The post has about 2,000 likes, 730 reposts and 32,000 views; the full video is embedded above.

What happened next

The IRS's own inspector general (TIGTA) confirmed it in May 2013: agents in Cincinnati had used a "Be on the Lookout" list to flag applications with names like "Tea Party" and "Patriots," left some of them pending through two election cycles, and asked some groups for things like their donors' names.

A week later, on May 22, Lois Lerner, who ran the IRS division that did it, told the House Oversight Committee, "I have not done anything wrong," then said she would not answer any questions, relying on her constitutional right not to testify (Fifth Amendment privilege). She was put on leave and retired that fall. Here is the clip:

Lois Lerner says she has done nothing wrong, then declines to answer the House Oversight Committee's questions, May 22, 2013 (video: Legal Insurrection). Watch on YouTube

Called back on March 5, 2014 — her second appearance — Lerner again refused. Chairman Darrell Issa read her own emails back to her and asked about them one by one; each time she answered, "On the advice of my counsel, I respectfully exercise my Fifth Amendment right and decline to answer that question." When Issa gave up and adjourned, he cut off ranking Democrat Elijah Cummings' microphone as he tried to speak. In May 2014 the House voted to hold her in contempt of Congress. Here is the second refusal:

Lois Lerner's second appearance before the House Oversight Committee, March 5, 2014: she again declines to answer Chairman Darrell Issa's questions (video: Washington Free Beacon). Watch on YouTube

Obama's Justice Department closed its criminal investigation in October 2015 without charging anyone. Its letter to Congress found "substantial evidence of mismanagement, poor judgment and institutional inertia" but said "poor management is not a crime."

In October 2017, Trump's Justice Department settled two of the groups' lawsuits. In a court consent order, the IRS admitted that screening the groups "based on their names or policy positions" and hitting them with "heightened scrutiny and inordinate delays" was wrong, and it said it "expresses its sincere apology." A separate class action covering 428 groups ended with a $3.5 million settlement, which a federal judge approved in 2018.

The lasting result wasn't a stricter IRS. It was a weaker one. The Washington Post reported in 2017 that the fallout from the scandal, along with years of budget cuts, had greatly diminished the agency's oversight of political activity by nonprofits. ProPublica found that the IRS's nonprofit division shrank from 942 staffers in 2010 to 585 in 2018.

More In Other News